Noah is described by Leon Kass in The Beginning of Wisdom and in Genesis as being righteous and simple, and is also known to have walked with God. Noah finds grace in the eyes of God because he avoids the sins of others. After discovering their own mortality following Adam’s natural death, the humans are enraged and shocked, and proceed to carry out many acts of wickedness and evil, giving into temptations of lust and heroics. In particular, the humans sin by taking wives based on their beauty and appearance. Noah is not attracted to any of these evils, and for that is favored by God. Noah’s narrative clearly related to the first sin of Genesis. Adam and Eve are instructed not to eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. The serpent tempts them to eat from the tree, and they give in, learning the ambiguous knowledge of all good and evil. This moment of the two humans eating the fruit and gaining knowledge can be compared to the moment in which Adam dies of old age and the rest of the humans learn that they are mortal. It differs in that it was not the human’s choice to “eat the fruit,” or to learn of their mortality, but nevertheless it is a similar situation.
Another way in which the concerns are furthered by Noah’s story is in his simple mindedness. Kass reasons about why Noah is put on such a high pedestal by God, and muses that, “…we suspect that Noah’s righteousness may be related to his simplicity, “(p. 163). This can also be compared to Adam before the first sin. Adam does not have the knowledge of good and evil, and is instead simple minded and innocent. He does not make any move to eat from the tree until the serpent appears. Noah is the same: He is also simple minded and uninterested by temptations. Where the two differ is that Noah is not innocent to the realities of the world. He is aware of his mortality and of the lust of others and does not give in to it, making him a mentally stronger and more virtuous human than the rest.
I like your comparison between Adam & Eve eating the fruit and Adam’s eventual death. Both of these moments are significant in that they offer an array of information to the humans who participated or witnessed them occurring. Why do you think Noah was immune to the evils other humans faced? Was it luck, the circumstances, or both? I also agree with this theme of simplicity and how ultimately it places humans in favor with God. What about simplicity do you think God admires or prides in?
LikeLike
I like your comparison of Noah to Adam before eating the fruit. I think if you wanted to, you could further your comparison by expanding on Noah when her curses his son. Do you think their sin is comparable in any way? As far as I understand, Noah didn’t break an agreement with God like Adam did, but something could be said about God’s trust and faith in humanity being shattered by both of them.
LikeLike
I like your comparison of Adam and Eve eating the fruit and humans first encountering natural death. The two situations really are similar in the idea that they both serve as a loss of innocence for humankind. I find it interesting that you label the eating of the fruit as something that was “not the human’s choice,” and was wondering what led to that conclusion? Were you thinking that this was inevitable because, as these stories suggest, humans are self-serving by nature and therefore were destined to take the fruit, or was it something else? I’m also curious to know if you think Noah is actually “more virtuous” than others, or did his situation and knowledge simply allow him to present himself in that way?
LikeLike
I thought your comparison of Adam and Noah was very interesting. They are very similar before the original sin. Do you think there are more similarities after Adam, and if you consider it, Noah sinned? It is revealed that Noah is not totally virtuous in the end, what do you think about that?
LikeLike