In the story, “Jacob Wrestles with God,” Jacob purposefully makes himself alone in the camp. A mysterious man comes to him and they wrestle until daybreak. In the process, the man touches the socket of Jacob’s hip, possibly permanently wrenching it. The man cannot overcome Jacob, and requests that he let him go, but Jacob enforces that he will not until the man blesses him. The man does bless him with a new name, Israel, meaning that Jacob has struggled with God. This seems to indicate that the mysterious man is God in some shape or form, or possibly a messenger of God. Kass says that generally, this man has been considered an angel, but I think that the text clearly points to him being God. The story is literally called, “Jacob Wrestles with God,” and Jacob claims that he saw God face to face. Additionally, Jacob asks for the man’s name, to which the man responds, “Why do you ask my name,” (Genesis 32:29). This could be interpreted as the man claiming that Jacob already knows him, being God. Either way, it is clear that in some way, this man is the voice of God.
In the end, Jacob does get his blessing, but it is unclear if he did actually win or not. Jacob is left with a limp. This, in some way, could be similar to God’s covenant with Abraham, which requires circumcision. Jacob is left with a mark that shows God’s power and superiority. Jacob is blessed, but is left with a limp that will force him to remember that God gave him that blessing. Additionally, Jacob, after having a past of concealing his name to others, reveals his name to the man. In a way, this could be a loss for him. He is submitting himself, and in that way is subordinate.
I like how you described how the man Jacob wrestles with must be related to God in some ways. I also really like how you rationalize the fact that it is God Himself, especially with the quote about asking for His name. You point out that Jacob, in some interpretations, lost the fight. Why do you think that winning/losing is significant to Jacob’s story and ultimately his relationships with Esau and God?
LikeLike
I agree that it is fairly unclear whether or not Jacob won. On one hand, he does emerge with a blessing and a new name, but on the other hand, as you pointed out, he is also given a limp. Do you think the ambiguity of this story in particular reflects the ambiguity of God Himself, or is its purpose more specific to Jacob’s story?
LikeLike
I agree that there is no clear winner in the fight and I liked how you characterized the man as God in a way. You did a good job using the text itself to support your claim. I think you could have pulled in the story of Esau more and used that to analyze the fight. Do you think the brothers relationship had anything to do with the fight?
LikeLike
In my own writing, I struggled with the debate over whether his opponent could be God, an angel, a man, or some combination of all three. If you believe his opponent to be God, then he should be all-powerful, so why would he give Jacob the satisfaction of a small victory? I know that Jacob is unique is his standing amongst humanity, but why would he be able to wrestle with a higher deity?
LikeLike